I have always used Airbake cookie sheets and love how easy they are and how great cookies bake on them. So, I baked half the batch on my usual Airbake sheet and half on my Pampered Chef stone.
It was a tough call and my husband and I really didn't want to participate but since no one else was around I guess we had to be the judges.
There really isn't a right answer to this test but we did both prefer the stone-baked cookies. The Airbake sheet made a softer, chewier cookie. The stone-baked cookie was crispy on the bottom and chewy in the center, just how we like it.
There was enough dough for about 6 more cookies so I decided to bake those in a muffin pan.
I was thinking that the muffin pan would make them all impressively perfect round cookies, which it did but it also made them small and fatter- like a one bite cookie. They weren't really big enough for me but I have a recipe for peanut butter & jelly cookies that I think would look great baked in this pan.
I may have to give this test a re-do soon just to be sure the results were accurate! ;)